Monday, May 31, 2010

As cars improve, are we actually seeing improvements in MPG?

I was astounded when I saw the advertisements for the 2011 Ford Mustang. 305 hp and 31 mpg on the highway. Considering two of the cars I have driven would return highway mpg in the low 30s but only offered about 100 and 225 hp (1988 Toyota MR2 and 1997 Volvo 850 Turbo, respectively), Ford's achievement seems truly astounding. Yet, as I marveled at that figure--and needled an old roommate, whose 2003 Mustang Mach 1 has only 330 hp but according to him is returning fuel economy of around 12 mpg--I realized I didn't actually know what the previous fuel economy figures for Mustangs were, and I also wondered what the city figure was.

A simple Google search led me to a post by The Auto Prophet, with a table showing various facts about base Mustangs including displacement, weight, horsepower and fuel economy. The chart revealed that, from 1993 to 2011, while displacement has increased by over 50% from a 2.3 liter four cylinder to a 3.7 liter V-6, and horsepower has nearly tripled from 105 to 305 hp, fuel economy figures have essentially stayed the same. City mpg for the 93 'Stang was 19, with a highway figure of 27. The Auto Prophet's figures for the 2011 Mustang are using the version equipped with a manual transmission. With an automatic, the 2011 model's fuel consumption is 19 mpg city and 31 mpg highway. The Auto Prophet took his figures to show just how far engine design has advanced since 1993, and thought that the figures painted an amazing picture. However, you could also say that regardless of the horsepower figures, in nearly 20 years the base Mustang's fuel economy has improved by less than 15%, and that's assuming all your driving is done on the highway.

I live in the DC metro area, and sitting in traffic is a way of life there. For me and anyone else who is stuck in traffic, the 2011 Mustang's highway mileage improvement is fairly moot. Even though the EPA tells me a 2011 Mustang is more efficient than the 1993 Mustang that's idling in traffic alongside me, the reality is that the 93's engine is doing just as good a job as mine is, despite the fact that his engine is based off one which was designed for the Ford Pinto back in 1974.

While other carmakers such as Toyota have made more significant improvements in fuel economy, it still feels like there are sleight-of-hand tricks going on. Even comparing the 2010 and 1993 Toyota Camry V-6 models, there is a gain of only about 20% in combined fuel economy. That is a gain of approximately 1.25% per year from one of the most fuel-efficient carmakers in the world. However, to meet the looming 2016 CAFE standards, fuel economy must increase by 5% per year.

Since cars have been getting heavier and more powerful with every new model released, any advances in fuel efficiency have been mostly canceled out. More advanced technologies such as low-rolling resistance tires will certainly help improve fuel economy figures, but those are quick-fixes which don't address the real issue: the lumps under the hood are too powerful, or being asked to haul too much weight. The 2016 CAFE standards make it clear that the current state of affairs is simply unsustainable. However, it is hard to believe that carmakers will be able to achieve the mandated improvements. Automakers, regulators, and consumers all try to assert their will when cars are being designed and sold. It remains to be seen who will have the greatest voice in the years to come.

Tuesday, July 24, 2007